1997 Oct 4 - Oct 29 : NewSfile #8
Senna trial: Head and Newey silent
1997 October 29
At today's hearing of the Senna death trial both Patrick Head
and Adrian Newey exercised their rights not to answer questions,
but opted to submit written statements to the court at a later
date. The proceedings were then adjourned awaiting the arrival
of Frank Williams.
Williams: Doubts about steering
Arriving late for this morning's session Frank Williams was
asked by the state prosecutor, Maurizio Passarini, about the
Williams teams own internal investigations.
Williams said: "We were looking for as much fact as possible
and were anxious to see as much television footage as we could."
"We as a company formed the opinion that the steering
column did not break. This was decided after examining the telemetry
readings and also a lot of simulations."
Williams went on to say that the team had considered various
explanations but he did not offer a theory for the cause of Ayrton
Senna's crash. He did remember that alterations were made to
the steering column after May 1.
"I remember that all the remaining cars were checked
and were OK. Even so we decided to change the columns and manufacture
different versions to remove any doubt about integrity."
Asked whether he had any doubts about Senna's steering column
Williams replied: "Absolutely. We had doubts, that's why
we're here today, trying to find out what happened."
Modifications made
Maurizio Passarini then questioned Williams about why the
modifications were made to Senna's steering column.
"Ayrton wanted more room in the cockpit and it was decided
to change this. When it was decided, I don't remember. There
would have been communication with all the relevant people.
"I can't be accurate or specific because I do not follow,
and never have done, every operation on a daily basis."
Williams said he didn't know who was responsible for making
the changes only that many people would have been involved.
"Senna made three or four pages of recommendations to
make the car go faster after every practice session. I remember
that he was not happy about the amount of space, and there were
also many other things he wanted to change.
"He also wanted a very large steering wheel, it was one
of his trademarks," he said.
Williams said that he was not personally aware that changes
had been made until after the race.
Passarini offered a judgment on Senna's opinion of the car
which Williams rejected saying: "The driver did not say
he could not drive the car, rather that he would like more space
so he would be less tired in the latter half of the race."
Metal fatigue
Attempting to press Williams further Passarini brought up
the fact that his (Williams) teams own experts had discovered
over 40 percent metal fatigue in Senna's steering column.
Williams added: "But I'm certain that the plane I arrived
in yesterday had cracks in it."
Pushed further with regard to any action he would have taken
had he known about the extent of the metal fatigue in Senna's
column, Frank Williams restated that he was not responsible for
technical issues.
At the start of the Senna trial on February 20 1997 Adrian
Newey's lawyers had argued that, as their client had been interviewed
previously as a witness not as an accused, much of the case against
him should be dismissed. This plea was reiterated again today.
Speaking to reporters later, Williams said: "We'll probably
never know what happened. But I made it clear in court today
that we think that the car probably left the road rather than
suffered a steering column failure."
Coulthard: Steering oscillations normal
Yesterday, October 28, David Coulthard, ex-test driver for
the Williams team in 1994, gave evidence. Coulthard testified
that the movement shown by Senna's steering column/wheel was
perfectly acceptable.
He stated that in 1994: It was normal for the Williams' steering
column to move both up and down and left and right by several
centimetres, and for the driver's hands to rub against the cockpit.
As the steering wheel was constructed of carbon fibre this would
also flex. Changes have been made to the regulations and this
year the collapsible steering wheels are much stiffer.
Passarini asked Coulthard if he knew how much play there was
in the steering column, independently of the steering wheel.
Coulthard retorted: No, I have never done this test, because
I have never driven a car without a steering wheel."
A video shown in the courtroom featured Coulthard sitting
in a stationary Williams F1 car showing the movement in the steering
wheel. Michele Alboreto who previously testified said that the
amount of play shown in Senna's car was abnormal.
Today Alboreto again stated that he had never before experienced
that behaviour in a steering wheel.
The next court session is presently scheduled for November
7.
The S Files
 |